
We were joined at the hip Habonim and I. My formative years were garbed up in my red laced blue shirt and faded Levi jeans. It was my fashion statement.
I belonged. I was part of the of Habonim, the labor Zionist youth movement.
But nine years old was I, when I spent my first summer at Camp Miriam. It was an all or nothing thing, as I found myself climbing up the rungs of the movement. At camp and at the “ken” (the movement’s un-summer city nest), at seminars and other trainings, I did it all: chanicha (camper) and madricha (counselor). Of course my gap year was spent immersed in Israel on “Workshop”, exploring and experiencing the culture and the life of Israel first hand. Everything was done by the book.
Ameliem? Check√ Chotrim? Check√ Tzofim? Check√ K’m Beit? Check√
All camper groups completed and accounted for. I did my stint as a counselor both at camp and in the “ken”. I came back from Israel to begin university and suddenly found myself milking cows at a nearby Washington dairy to save up money for my last and final stint.
Like I said, I did it all, part and parcel, and found myself embracing the movement’s ultimate calling: I made Aliyah to a kibbutz in Israel.
“If you will it, it is no dream”…
My path is a vision.

Once I was a bulldozer, now I am but a rake…
I was hard. I would not allow any ideas other than mine to permeate. Hard is fragile, solitary. I wanted more so I embraced change.
I softened. I actually listened and lay down my arms. Lo and behold, I discovered that the world is not two-dimensional. Not everything is black and white: Fifty Shades? Well, that's just the tip of the iceberg. The vision may be perfect, but the people sure aren’t…
Many beautiful memories from our life on the kibbutz remain. Although, at times, life on a kibbutz felt like a huge extended family complete with the gossip, the petty fights and the drama.
Kibbutz was a lesson in socialism: “From each according to his ability, to each according to his needs.” At times, however, it was more along the lines of “what is yours is mine and what is mine is mine”…
Kibbutz life had its unique systems. One such example was the free goods distribution. Kibbutz members were free to help themselves to produce from the communal refrigerator and from the self-service food carts in the main dining room. In the early days of the kibbutz such things as cigarettes, sugar, salt, bread, eggs, fruit and vegetables were freely available for all to take.
In the beginning there was trust. It was clear that each member would only take according to his needs.
Big mistake!
Unfortunately, the needs and the boundaries are as clear as the collective integrity.
In time, the distribution method changed and allotments per member or family size were instituted. For example, a family of five would receive three baskets of fruit while a couple would receive only one. Alas, this system also had its faults.
Not all members wanted fruit. Some preferred to snack on other foods. There was no choice, no alternative provided.
Even if there was a preference for a different type of fruit: there was no choice, no alternative provided.
My share – My take!
What a waste!
I recall my adopted kibbutz father passionately repeating the ongoing saga of “The Fruit at Mom’s”.
He came to visit his parents. He opened the refrigerator and was immediately accosted by fruit, lots of fruit. He turned around and saw fruit, lots more on the table behind.
Astonished, he confronted his mother. “Ema (Mom)! The fridge is overflowing with fruit. Why did you bring more?!”
His mother answered deservingly: “It’s mine! Why should I not take it?!”
It turns out that a utopian society needs perfect people. The big guy upstairs appears to have messed that one up…
Free has a price tag!
As a child, my family dined out frequently. We especially liked buffets. We were free to pick and choose again and again. It was conquer and destroy, a battle zone in our wake. We escaped weary and breathless, heavily burdened with our exploits.
Later as parents, we too preferred a good buffet. Frequently we would also seek out hotels with a buffet. There were food choices for every palate, no opportunity for the kids to complain. Everyone walked away happy (except, of course, the cleanup crew…).
Supersize?
The fast food industry discovered many marketing incentives to get us in the doors. For a pittance, they offered to enlarge our meals. They gave us large soft drink cups with free access to endless refills.
Big Eyes

Our appetite is insatiable. A wedding would not be complete without tasting the whole spread. A spectacular find at the clothing boutique would not feel right without a multiple color purchase.
There is an easy payment plan available for every dream. So what if you can’t afford it!

One of the first concepts taught in Economics 101 is the “elasticity of demand”. This concept measures the percentage change in product demand as compared to the percentage change in price.
When the elasticity of demand is inelastic, one will purchase the same amount of a product regardless of its price. Household salt and tap water are two good examples of products with a relatively inelastic demand.
Another example of inelastic demand is a diabetic’s need for insulin. A diabetic will continue to buy the same amount of insulin every week regardless of its price as his demand for the product is fixed.
On the other hand, however, the demand for organic bread is quite elastic. As its price drops it is more than likely that many will prefer it over ordinary bread, however, when the price is high few will purchase as there are many lower priced alternatives to organic bread.
Nothing is Free!
A tiny price tag comes at a HUGE cost…
Take government subsidies for example. A government spends money to lower the price of essential goods. Is this decision a reflection of the government’s intent to aid the producer or rather the weak consumer? On which product is the emphasis focused? Does it become an attempt to find the easiest and cheapest way to feed the weak, regardless of the havoc it will play with our health? Would it be so wrong if whole food plant choices were the standard? It is all too easy to push the substandard white sugary choices. Really, is white bread and lot fed flesh what the doctor ordered?
It saddens me to see bumper crops dumped and burned to keep market prices up. What a wonderful world it would be if there were fruits and vegetables freely available to hungry families…
When I travel I love to explore farmers’ markets. The vibrant colors, spectacular flavors and unique handcrafts will draw me in time and time again. Just before we came home from this summer’s trip we stopped to explore the Union Square Farmer’s Market. Some official signs aroused my curiosity and I went up to the booth to understand to meaning of what I read. It appears that eligible food stamp holders may choose to exchange their food dollars for market coins. For every five dollars of food stamps exchange the bearer will receive seven dollars of market money. Simply stated, this provides the bearer with an extra 40% value which can be used on all food and beverages (solely) in the market! Talk about added value…
It excites me to see the abundant health initiatives of the mayor of N.Y.C. Besides the market money program, he is responsible for creating an upper limit for soft drink beverage cups, prohibiting the sale of foods with trans fats, designing a healthy teacher’s training, creating school gardens and school salad bars.
Salad Bars?
Can you imagine if we had a salad bar in every school, work place, play place and well place? Despite being a “less is more” kind of gal, I would LOVE to see more of this!
Let’s talk about it!
I would like to thank you for your patience in reading this post to its end.
If you liked what you read and you are not on my mailing list, you can sign up here.
Finally I would like to request that you please share my post which precedes the release of my animated clip (soon, I promise). I am so excited! Please share this post…
Thank you and have a great week!

















Hey Paula
Obesity and chronic disease are rampant. The NYC Food Bucks is a government incentive to fight it. I invite you to learn more at http://www.grownyc.org/greenmarket/ebt. I also found this interesting http://www.cdc.gov/pcd/issues/2013/12_0285.htm
Don't you just love the new creative efforts to push us back to healthy?! Happy to give you food for thought. Please pop in sometime and I will give you more than that
🙂 Helene
I like what NYC is doing from what I hear too. Not sure I understand the reason for trading in $5 food stamps for $7?
Fun to see you're evolution… you give us much food for thought Helene.
Paula